Photo: Craig Melvin Instagram

It’s a family affair!
Craig Melvinrallied behind his daughter Sybil on Tuesday as she got her ears pierced for her fifth birthday. TheTodayco-anchor, 41 — who claims he’s “not a spontaneous kind of guy” — reflected on joining in on the experience.
On Wednesday, Melvin explained to his co-hosts that his daughter Sybil, whom he shares with wife Lindsay Czarniak, wanted to get her ears pierced as a birthday present, but when the time came, she asked her dad to get a piercing too.
“When we got there, she was like, ‘Daddy, would you do yours first?'” he said onToday. “And I was like, ‘Uhhh…'”
Craig Melvin Instagram

Melvin ultimately supported his little girl, getting a black onyx stud in his left ear. He also revealed that Czarniak and their son Delano, 7, got their ears pierced too.
“She convinced us all to do it. A family that pierces together stays together. That’s the saying right???” Melvin wrote onInstagramalongside a photo of the family showing off their new ear piercing.
Czarniak also shared an adorable photo of Melvin holding Sybil’s hand as she prepared for the big moment.
Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Lindsay Czarniak Instagram

During the morning show, Melvin said his daughter was thrilled about the family event and her new Hello Kitty earrings, calling it a “great bonding” moment for the family of four.
WhenSavannah Guthrieasked, “Wow, so are you going to keep it,” Melvin hesitantly responded, “Well, I don’t think … we’ll see.”

Melvin later shared to his co-hosts that he and his wife are still planning to throw Sybil a birthday party.
“We’ll do a traditional birthday party where we’ll have to spend two hours explaining to all of our family and friends why it is we’re all walking around with pierced ears,” he joked.
source: people.com