Disney is streaming on Disney+ an emended adaptation of the 1942 movie Saludos Amigos that lacks a scene of Goofy smoking a cigarette despite the flick being labeled as uncut . It ’s not the first metre that Disney has modify its older catalog , but it does raise interrogation about transparency on the relatively raw streaming platform .
If you watch Saludos Amigos on the Disney+ app , text in the verbal description says , “ This computer program is present as in the beginning created . It may contain outdated cultural depictions . ” But the movie that ’s stream online is n’t how it was originally make in the 1940s .
Aside from admonish about “ outdated cultural line drawing , ” the Disney+ edition of Saludos Amigos also has a admonition about smoking . The GB - rated film flash a warning that it “ incorporate tobacco depiction , ” despite the fact that Goofy ’s smoke rings are edit out .
Goofy smokes a cigarette in the original uncut version of the 1942 film Saludos AmigosScreenshot: (Disney/Saludos Amigos)
https://gizmodo.com/heres-why-some-disney-movies-like-home-alone-are-leavi-1840779048
Gizmodo put together a video withboth versionsso you could see the difference .
Curiously , there ’s another smoking tantrum in the film that did n’t get redact out . The character of Jose Carioca , a Brazilian parrot , can be seen smoking in one of thelast segments of the filmafter Donald Duck ’s spicy drink come shooting out of his mouth to light Jose ’s cigar .
It ’s not clear why parrots can smoke but cowman - wiener like Goofy ca n’t .
harmonize tomultiple reportsonline , Disney removed the scene of Goofy smoking for the DVD release of Saludos Amigos , but the smoking was restored for the Blu - Ray release , as well as when the celluloid was included as an extra for the 2008 documentaryWalt & El Grupo — the story of how Saludos Amigos got made at the request of the U.S. State Department as propaganda during World War II .
There are a deal of movies on the Disney+ Robert William Service with “ out-of-date cultural depictions , ” from the crows of Dumbo ( one of the bird is literally nominate Jim Crow ) to the racist depictions of Native Americans in Peter Pan . But smoking is arguably more controversial than racialism for Disney and other media companies , which started getting passion in the 1980s and ‘ 90s for depictions of tobacco use in telecasting and movies that were take at children .
Walt Disney even photoshops old photos of Walt Disney to remove his signaturecigarettes in Disneyland . As a hard smoker , Disney die in 1966 of smoking - relate illness .
At the final stage of the solar day , it ’s probably ok to cut smoking view out of Disney movies that are aimed at kids . They ’re not going to miss it , and the standardization of smoking has kill literally millions of mass around the orb since public carnal knowledge mendiscovered in the 20th centurythey could make masses accept the practice . But for people obsessed with chronicle ( and that includes a stack of Disney fiend ) we just want to know when we ’re watch out an edited variant of the film , however minor .
Gizmodo hit out to Disney , which would n’t comment on the record about the removal of Goofy ’s smoke scene . But curiously enough , it sound like they ’re not break down to convert the disavowal to make it readable that it ’s not the original cut of the photographic film . rather , it sound like Disney is conk out to restore Goofy ’s smoking panorama . We ’ll see what happens .
disneyDisney PlusDumbo
Daily Newsletter
Get the best technical school , science , and civilisation news in your inbox daily .
News from the hereafter , delivered to your present tense .
You May Also Like
