John Walter Lay.Photo:Justice4Walt/ Facebook
Justice4Walt/ Facebook
The West Dog Park in Tampa, Fla., was John Walter Lay’s home away from home. It’s where he made numerous friends and let his beloved dog Fala run free every day. But to the shock of his loved ones, it’s also where Lay, 52, was shot and killed on Feb. 2.
The gunman was identified as Gerald Declan Radford, 65, another frequent park goer, but he is currentlynot facing any chargesin connection with the fatal shooting, according to the Hillsborough County Sheriff’s Office. Four days after the shooting, the sheriff’s office said “there is no danger to the public,” but now a month later, they say the investigation is still active.
Radford claims that Lay attacked him and the shooting was self-defense, but Lay’s friends believe it was a targeted attack — and they have video evidence they say bolsters their claim.
In a video that Lay — who friends affectionately called Walt — sent to his best friend and fellow dog park visitor Kim Wolfley one day before he was killed, he relays a tense encounter he allegedly had with Radford that morning.
“So this morning while I’m walking, we’re the only two here, and he comes up to me and screams at me, ‘You’re going to die, you’re going to die,’ and I asked him to just leave me alone, and so far he has,” Lay says in the video, which Wolfley didn’t see until after Lay was killed the following day.
“This to me sounds like it was premeditated,” Wolfley, who met Lay at the dog park more than five years ago, tells PEOPLE. “It just floored me when I saw the video.”
John Walter Lay with his dog Fala.Courtesy Photo
Courtesy Photo
Samantha Hitchcock, another friend of Lay’s, alleges that Radford had harassed Lay for at least two and a half years before the shooting. She also claims to have heard Radford hurl homophobic slurs at both her and Lay on numerous occasions — and said that she knew Radford carried a gun in his truck.
“Walt never instigated anything at all,” Hitchcock tells PEOPLE. “He always walked away. He would say, ‘Leave me alone.’ He was just that type of person.”
John Walter Lay and Kim Wolfley’s dog Loki.Courtesy Photo
Lay and Radford would disagree on topics such as politics and vaccines, according to Wolfley, but Lay consistently tried to distance himself from Radford as much as he could while they were both at the park.
“[Radford] just started feeling ostracized, or as an outcast, he apparently told somebody,” Wolfley believes. “And his hatred just increased.”
Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up forPEOPLE’s free True Crime newsletterfor breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.
But Lay’s friends — including Wolfley, who remembers her best friend as “the funniest, kindest, gentlest soul who you could ever meet” — have never believed this version of events.
Hitchcock claims that three years ago she had a confrontation with Radford, which ended with him calling her homophobic slurs, and Lay witnessed it. She says Lay was the one who encouraged her to walk away from Radford instead of continuing to fight.
“That’s the type of man Walt was,” she says. “He didn’t believe in confrontation at all. I went through some of the hardest times in my life, and the dog park was where I found peace, because I was able to actually sit down with Walt in the afternoons, in the mornings, and actually talk to him about it when it was just him and I.”
John Walter Lay and Luna, another one of Kim Wolfley’s dogs.Courtesy Photo
source: people.com
